NRL News

Don’t make disability an issue in abortion debate, says Irish health minister

by | Jan 4, 2018

Simon Harris “abhors” abortion for disability–but not all disabilities

By SPUC—the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children

Simon Harris is “not ashamed” that he has changed his view on abortion.

Irish health minister Simon Harris has “warned” campaigners not to make non-fatal disability an issue during the referendum on the Eighth Amendment, the Times reports.

“The committee [considering the Eighth Amendment] did not recommend disability as a grounds for abortion nor do I think it should have, I would abhor that idea,” Mr. Harris said. “People may try to make this an issue during the campaign but it’s not grounds for an abortion. If you look at what the committee considered and what it accepted and rejected, the idea of abnormalities that are not fatal was not put in as a grounds for abortion.”

Misleading terms

While the committee rejected the legalization of abortion on grounds of “foetal abnormality” that would not lead to death before or shortly after birth, it recommended abortion up to birth for “fatal foetal abnormality.”

Organisations such as Every Life Counts campaign against terms such as “incompatible with life” and “fatal foetal abnormality” as being “hurtful, medically meaningless and misleading.”

Disability bias

As Martin McCaffery, a neonatologist and professor of pediatrics at the university of North Carolina, wrote in the Irish Times, the committee did not hear “from one physician describing counselling in which parents are told that with continued care their anencephalic child would likely be born alive, have a meaningful if short life, and the child’s birth would reduce later maternal mental health challenges. No doctor testified that labelling infants with trisomy 18 as ‘lethal’ is inaccurate and steeped in disability bias.”

The committee also recommended permitting abortion with no restrictions up to 12 weeks, and up until birth on the grounds of the mother’s mental health, both of which grounds could be used to target children with disabilities.

Targeting the most vulnerable

“It is clear that the health minister wants to distance himself from the unpleasant reality that the proposed legislation would certainly lead to babies with disabilities being aborted simply because they are disabled.” SPUC’s Dr. Anthony McCarthy commented. “Bearing in mind that ‘fatal foetal abnormality’ is not a medical term, and most babies with life-limiting conditions do live for some time after birth, what he is actually saying is that babies with more severe disabilities than others do not deserve to live.”


Mr. Harris, who previously described himself as pro-life, also told the Times that “I did completely change my mind on abortion. I don’t know why I had the initial view I had. I came into the Dáil [the lower house of the Irish Parliament] at 24 years of age, never had kids and I just had a traditional view. Since becoming a TD [member of the Dáil] and particularly since becoming health minister, the more I meet people and listen to their experiences I genuinely have had a radical change in my view on this. I am not ashamed to say that.”

He also denied reports that the Government was planning to postpone the referendum.

Categories: Abortion Ireland