NRL News

Opponents and disability rights activists take concerns about liberalizing euthanasia laws to Members of Canadian Parliament

by | Apr 4, 2018

By Deborah Gyapong

Editor’s note. This was published by the Catholic Register on April 3 and reposted by the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition.

Alex & Susan Schadenberg with
Taylor Hyatt and Bev Shipley (MP)

Euthanasia opponents and disability rights activists are uneasy about a process to liberalize Canada’s euthanasia law — a law which they say still lacks regulations and proper safeguards.

“I’m very concerned about the direction of things,” said Alex Schadenberg, executive director of the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition.

Schadenberg and Taylor Hyatt, policy analyst and outreach co-coordinator for the disability rights group Not Dead Yet, spent two days during the last week of March visiting about a half dozen Members of Parliament to outline their issues with the laws governing assisted suicide, which has been legal in Canada since June 2016.

“One thing I especially wanted to bring up was the many holes in assisted suicide monitoring,” said Hyatt. “I hope we can bring a disability rights analysis into this and see that in the quest to pursue death so quickly, so many questions are being left untouched.”

Hyatt pointed out that in 2016 Health Canada asked the Council of Canadian Academies (CCA), an independent private research organization, to examine the possible expansion of Canada’s so-called Medical Aid in Dying (MAiD) law to include mature minors, allow advanced directives for those with a dementia diagnosis, and allow MAiD for those with psychological suffering without the necessity of death being reasonably foreseeable.

“We’re talking about the direction of the Council of Canadian Academies,” said Schadenberg. “We’re concerned about where it’s going.”

While the CCA has solicited input, its process is “completely closed,” said Hyatt, whose group did make a submission to the CCA.

CCA set up an “Expert Panel on Medical Assistance in Dying” and, according to its website, it will “not be making policy or other recommendations. It also will not be recommending changes to the current legislation or seeking views and opinions on the topic of MAiD more generally.”

The CCA set up three panels to study each area of possible expansion of assisted suicide. Each panel is preparing drafts of its findings for final meetings in November. The CCA will submit its reports to the government by the end of 2018.

“We have no idea of how the government plans to move on it, whether immediately or not,” said Schadenberg. “This leaves people outside of the Prime Minister’s Office having no idea of what they’re going to do.”

Schadenberg pointed out the federal government is funding this process, but its experts examining the questions have “a separation from Members of Parliament.” The fact they are separate “makes it hard to lobby them.”

The pair also informed MPs about the research Hyatt has done on the draft guidelines for assisted suicide across Canada.

“There’s enough holes in these guidelines that you can drive a hearse through them,” said Schadenberg.

Hyatt and Not Dead Yet’s executive director Amy Hasbrouck, sent a nearly 30-page study of the guidelines to Health Canada last year.

Among the criticisms is the “lack of demographic information on the people who are seeking death,” said Hyatt. “It’s the name, the address, basic things, but no information on what accessibility needs are going unmet in their lives.”

Questions such as where they are living, whether they are homeless or in a long-term home, or if there are “any other issues where their circumstances are pressuring them to end their lives, are going unnoticed,” she said.

Hasbrouck had also done an analysis of euthanasia in Quebec and it “shows you that already the safeguards that are in place are being broken or being violated,” Hyatt said.

Another concern about the guidelines or regulations is they “base everything” on a “good faith” analysis, which is “the lowest possible standard,” said Schadenberg. “When I’m dead by lethal injection, therefore, and there might be some questions about the decision about my death, the only question to the physician then is, ‘Was this done in good faith?’”

Categories: Euthanasia