NRL News

Scotland is being pressured to legalize assisted suicide. They need to care not kill.

by | Apr 22, 2019

By Alex Schadenberg, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition

Dr. Gordon Macdonald

Dr. Gordon Macdonald, the parliamentary officer for “Care for Scotland,” wrote an excellent article that was published in the Scotsman on April 19, explaining why assisted suicide should not be legalised.

Under the headline “Legalizing assisted suicide is a start of a slippery slope,” Macdonald begins by discussing why the previous assisted suicide bill in 2015 was defeated.

A new campaign has been launched in the Scottish Parliament by a cross-party group of MSPs [Members of the Scottish Parliament] to legalise assisted suicide. They plan to bring forward proposals for a new law before the next Scottish parliament election in 2021.

The last time MSPs voted on the issue of assisted suicide in 2015, they rejected Patrick Harvie’s Assisted Suicide Bill by 82-36. It was a clear, comprehensive victory. If you listen back to the speeches made during that debate, it was clear that MSPs did not think the law could be made safe.

Most members realised then that the risks of legalising assisted suicide were too high and would put vulnerable people at risk of harm.

But pro-assisted suicide advocates, including a few MSPs, are determined to change the law in Scotland. The well-funded, London–based campaign group Dignity in Dying are taking their campaign to Scotland. They are saying that if they can change the law in Scotland, it will put huge pressure on the rest of the United Kingdom to follow suit. They are fundraising so they can buy billboards, posters and placards in order to pressurise MSPs to change the law.

Macdonald argues that legalizing assisted suicide will negatively affect their caring society:

Scotland has a long and proud history as being a compassionate, caring society where we look after each other. Assisted suicide would undermine this heritage in a radical and unalterable way.

It would also undermine palliative care, put vulnerable people at risk and put doctors in an invidious position. It would heap pressure on some of the most vulnerable in society to end their life, perhaps prematurely because they feel as though they are a burden to loved ones or caregivers. Such an outcome is unavoidable. Instead of encouraging suicide, we should be helping people to see that they are valuable and of worth to family, friends and society, even in old age or experiencing ill-health.

Macdonald then explains how assisted suicide laws in other jurisdictions have expanded to include other categories of people:

When introduced, assisted suicide laws might be focused on a certain, set of circumstances. As time goes on, the categories of eligibility extend to include more and more people. It can quickly expand from the terminally ill to include those with chronic illnesses, but not terminal conditions; from adults to children; from those with physical illness to include those who have psychiatric and psychological problems and even dementia.

There are proposals in some countries to extend laws to include elderly people who are just tired of life and suggestions that elderly people over a certain age should not get significant medical assistance if they are unwell.

There is a case at the European Court on Human Rights where three doctors are being investigated after a 64-year-old Belgian woman in good health with depression was euthanised, despite there being no official diagnosis. Her son only found out about it when the hospital contacted him to arrange the disposal of her remains.

In the USA there are instances of people been denied health insurance for cancer treatment whilst being offered funding to commit suicide. We would be naïve to assume that such cases will not also happen here.

Macdonald then explains why assisted suicide safeguards could never work:

It’s not good enough to talk about safeguards when the evidence suggests there is no way assisted suicide legislation could ever be made fully safe from abuse. Is this really the sort of society in which we want to live? In Scotland, our Christian tradition has left a legacy of concern for the most vulnerable and a sense of responsibility to look after those unable to care for themselves.

Sadly, our culture too readily equates dependence and vulnerability with weakness. But being vulnerable helps us to realise our dependence upon other human beings.

Dr. Gordon Macdonald has been a long-time promoter of the belief that society needs to care for its citizens, not kill them.

Editor’s note. This appeared on Mr. Schadenberg’s blog and is reposted with permission.

Categories: Assisted Suicide