NRL News
202.626.8824
dadandrusk@aol.com

Swiss assisted suicide doctor does not support euthanasia

Dec 6, 2021

By Alex Schadenberg, Executive Director, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition

Erika Preisig

Erika Preisig is a doctor and president of assisted suicide organisation Lifecircle. She was recently asked in an interview, with Swissinfo, if Switzerland should allow euthanasia rather than assisted suicide? 

She answered NO and stated:

I don’t want to kill anybody.

Preisig correctly differentiates assisted suicide, which is a self-administered suicide death from euthanasia, which is done by lethal injection administered by someone else.

Preisig explains how assisted suicide is possible in all medical conditions, except locked-in syndrome.

To be clear, I don’t support euthanasia or assisted suicide but Preisig’s comments are contrary to the comments made by Dr. Shavelson in a California court case. He argues that the California assisted suicide law discriminates against people with certain conditions because they are unable to “self-administer.” The California court case, is attempting to permit euthanasia within the assisted suicide law.

Preisig didn’t stop there. When asked if the Swiss system is better than the Netherlands system, she responds Yes and stated:

In my opinion, the Swiss model is the best option. Here, the patient has the final say on his/her life.

Doctors should not decide whether a life is not worth living. If doctors can give the injection, how can you be sure that this was really the patient’s wish?

Preisig is not consistent in her message. Concerning euthanasia (death by lethal injection), how can you be sure that this was really the patient’s wish?  She also ignores the clear history of where legalizing assisted suicide leads:

People always talk about the slippery slope this could lead to and potential abuse. But this has never happened in Switzerland, nor in Canada, where euthanasia is legal. 

Preisig’s statement about the slippery slope (or potential abuse) not happening in Switzerland or Canada is clearly a false statement. Canada  and Switzerland have expanded their reasons for allowing assisted suicide and euthanasia. 

However, I agree with her completely;  doctors should not decide whether a person’s life is worth living. Further to that, she is also right that it is impossible to be sure that euthanasia was really a patient’s wish.

Abuse of the law

In October 2019, a Geneva court gave a suspended sentence to the regional vice-president of EXIT, Pierre Beck, for assisting the suicide of an 86-year-old woman who was not sick.  According to Swissinfo, Beck admitted to acting beyond the criteria of the law but he said that he didn’t regret his action and faced with a similar situation he would likely do it again.

In August 2016, Candice Lewis (25) while receiving treatment at a Newfoundland hospital was pressured to “request” an assisted death

No one questions that Candice was very sick, but as Candice’s mother told CBC News, the doctor pressured her to request physician-assisted death, Candice never asked for it.

Preisig then appears to contradict herself. She states:

Five years ago, I was charged with murder of a very old Swiss lady. She had been at a psychiatric ward for three months and was diagnosed with depression. I had a talk with her son, the chief of the nursing home where she was staying and her caretaker. But I couldn’t find a psychiatrist for the assessment.

When you face a court case for murder, and you think you have done everything perfectly right…. you ask yourself, why am I putting myself through this? And you think, why don’t I quit (laughter)? But there are so many people who trust me and need my help. This is why I keep going.

It is interesting that she does not recognize that it is impossible to confirm that the elderly depressed lady with questionable competency and ability to consent freely deciding to die. She then says people trust her to provide them the lethal drug cocktail for suicide and that is why she continues.

Editor’s note. This appeared on Mr. Schadenberg’s blog and is reposted with permission.

Categories: Assisted Suicide
Tags: