NRL News

Canada is failing its pregnant women

by | Jan 5, 2022

By We Need a Law

Women who choose motherhood should be honored and respected in that choice. Allowing offenders to get away, quite literally, with murder does nothing to empower women or protect real choice.

It is well established that the risk of violence against women increases when they are pregnant[1], yet consequences for their attackers do not increase at all. Right now, pre-born children are not recognized as persons for the purpose of the law, so their death or injury as victims of crime cannot be legally counted.

Victims unrecognized by Canada’s law:


Manjit Panghali, along with her pre-born child, was killed and then set on fire by her husband. She was identifiable only by dental records. Her husband was charged with only one count of murder.


Tashina General was strangled by her boyfriend while pregnant with a son she had named Tucker. The killer was charged with one count of murder and served less than 10 years in prison.


Cassandra Kaake was murdered when she was 7 months pregnant with a girl she had already named Molly. Cassandra’s killer was charged with one count of murder.


Arianna Goberdhan was 9 months pregnant when she was murdered by her husband in Pickering, Ontario. Her pre-born daughter, whom she had named Asaara, was also killed in the attack. Her husband was charged with one count of murder.

Each of these men knew the woman they were attacking was pregnant. They didn’t care. And neither does our justice system.

The stories could go on – there are more than 80 cases in recent Canadian history, and those are only stories of those women who died along with their pre-born children. Many others face assaults that harm both them and their pre-born children. It is time for legislators to ensure that true justice is served in the case of violent crime against pregnant women.

Canada’s lack of abortion law should not detract from the injustices these women and children faced. Canada needs a pre-born victims of crime law so criminals who would attack a pregnant woman can be sentenced appropriately by our courts. These children matter, regardless of their location at the time of the crime. These women matter, mothers who desire life for both themselves and their babies.

[1] See, for example, the World Health Organization’s Information Sheet on Intimate Partner Violence During Pregnancy, the Domestic Violence Fact Sheet from the National Coalition Against Domestic Violence, and J. Jasinski (2001) Pregnancy and Violence Against Women: An Analysis of Longitudinal DataJournal of Interpersonal Violence, 16 (7).

Categories: Canada