NRL News

Michigan courts wrangle at whiplash speed over enforcement of 1931 pro-life law

by | Aug 2, 2022

By Bettina di Fiore

The state of Michigan has a 1931 law on the books which not only prohibits most abortions, but also criminalizes the act of committing one. In anticipation of the potential overturning of Roe v. Wade, Planned Parenthood of Michigan filed suit in April to block Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel from enforcing the law. Nessel stated that she would not defend the state in the lawsuit, and agreed with Planned Parenthood’s position that the law is unconstitutional. The law states:

Any person who shall willfully administer to any pregnant woman any medicine, drug, substance or thing whatever, or shall employ any instrument or other means whatever, with intent thereby to procure the miscarriage of any such woman, unless the same shall have been necessary to preserve the life of such woman, shall be guilty of a felony, and in case the death of such pregnant woman be thereby produced, the offense shall be deemed manslaughter.

But whether that law will go back into effect remains to be seen, as legal ups and downs have been happening so quickly in Michigan that it is difficult to keep track of the law’s status at any given moment.

Court of Claims Judge Elizabeth Gleicher – who admits to making annual donations to Planned Parenthood – was assigned to the case. In May, she issued a temporary injunction prohibiting enforcement of the 1931 law, arguing that Planned Parenthood had a reasonable chance of winning its case. Although the Michigan legislature attempted to secure Judge Gleicher’s recusal from the case on the grounds that she could not be impartial in a case concerning an organization she obviously supported, she refused, saying the legislature’s argument “border[ed] on frivolous.”

After Judge Gleicher issued the injunction, a group of Michigan county prosecutors asked the Court of Appeals to rule on whether the temporary injunction applied to them. On Monday, August 1, the Court of Appeals determined that “[b]ecause county prosecutors are local officials, jurisdiction of the Court of Claims does not extend to them.” 

Some Republican county prosecutors pledged to enforce the law, while at least seven Democratic prosecutors said they would decline to do so.

However, just hours later, at the behest of Governor Gretchen Whitmer’s attorneys, Oakland County Judge Jacob Cunningham issued a restraining order against county prosecutors, and scheduled a hearing for Wednesday, August 3. 

The ultimate outcome remains unknown.

Governor Gretchen Whitmer has filed a separate lawsuit concerning the 1931 law. The Michigan Supreme Court has not yet stated whether it will hear the case. Meanwhile, pro-abortion activists have submitted over 750,000 signatures in an effort to get a measure on the ballot this fall which, if passed, would change Michigan’s constitution to permanently protect abortion.

Editor’s note. This appeared at Live Action News and is reposted with permission.

Categories: Judicial